Homestyle Apple Pie (Local Pick-Up ONLY)

You know you need one.

Our classic apple pie is made with fresh apples, hand peeled by your favorite baker-besties (and occasionally Lauren’s Grandpa, our favorite intern). We sweeten and spice the fruit to perfection, and pile on our DELICIOUS oaty crumble.

Craving something more decadent? We take this classic to the next level by coating our apples in caramel goodness for our Salted Caramel Apple Pie.

Pies will be available for pick-up WEDNESDAY 11/27 at 2 locations!

Bensonhurst, Brooklyn - Eleganz Plus 7400 20th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204
Mamaroneck, Westchester - Swim Tank 120 Madison St, Mamaroneck, NY 10543
Please specify at checkout which location you will be picking up at! 
Baker's Notes
  • Made from scratch, by hand, always
  • Baked fresh with real ingredient (with no icky preservatives)
  • Cheerfully taste and recipe-tested by us (it's a tough job!)
  • Instant happiness factor: 10/10
Serving Suggestion
  • Our 9” pies can be cut into 8 generous slices!
Freshness & Storage
  • Our pies keep best in the refrigerator. For maximum deliciousness, we recommend heating up pies in the oven. It’s easy, don’t worry! Just set your oven to 350* and bake for 15 minutes. Alternatively, remove from the refrigerator 1-2 hours before serving to enjoy at room temperature.
Shipping & Delivery
  • Unfortunately, we are unable to ship full-sized pies at this time. You may pick up your pies at our Westchester Pop Up on 11/26 and at our Brooklyn Pop Up on 11/27. You’ll be sent detailed pick-up instructions in your confirmation email.
  • *All of our products are made in a bakery that processes peanuts, tree nuts, soy, wheat, dairy and eggs


This product is currently sold out.

Please fill in the form below if you'd like to be notified when it becomes available.